Print Friendly and PDF

TSX Takeover Offer:
Trinidad Drilling

Benj Gallander and Ben Stadelmann, Contra the Heard, preparations for Thanksgiving were interrupted by the welcome news of a friendly offer from Precision Drilling (PD) to purchase Trinidad Drilling (TDG), a holding in their Vice-President’s Portfolio, that exceeded the value of Ensign´s hostile bid. Ensign proposed a $1.68 in cash after TDG´s strategic review process came within a whisker of concluding a sale to an unidentified party last July. “The hostile bid was viewed as opportunistic by the analyst community and was significantly below the average twelve-month price target.

By contrast, Precision´s deal values Trinidad at $1.98 (based on Precision´s prior close) and is a 1 for 0.445 shares exchange. By swapping shares, Trinidad owners will have the opportunity to participate in upside should the oil rally continue. Naturally all-cash offers where one can take the money and run do have their attraction.

On some levels, PD´s offer appears to make sense strategically and operationally. The combination is expected to generate annual operating savings of $30 million, result in the sale of 50 older rigs and increase the international reach of both organizations. That sounds yummy, but almost certainly there will also be major write-downs, squishing the combined book value. Some might argue that it would be a merger of two money-losing weaklings.

Behind the scenes both management teams appear to keenly believe in the prospects of their respective companies. TDG has seen net insider buying of $628,175 over the last year while PD has seen net insider buying of $626,951.

The transaction is expected to close before year end with two-thirds of TDG owners needing to vote in favour of the transaction. While Trinidad cannot solicit third party bids, management can accept a higher offer and pay a breakup fee of $20 million should a superior proposition emerge.

Will it? Ensign would be more likely than a new contender although that would mean quite an increase from the $1.68. That said, Ensign´s balance sheet is weak and small versus Precision´s. If the two organizations were to engage in a protracted bidding war the latter has more ammunition.

We are assessing the merits of owning the combined TDG/PD entity. In the meantime, the position will be held as the parties work towards closing the deal.”

Source: Benj Gallander is co-founder & President of Contra the Heard investment newsletter and manages the President’s Portfolio. Stock picks have returned 22.5% over the past 5 years and 16.7% over the last 15 years.  Ben Stadelmann, co-founder manages the Vice-President’s Portfolio which also has impressive returns over the last five years. They are considered Canada’s foremost contrarian investors. For more information: Contra the Heard, 42 Rivercrest Rd., Toronto, ON M6S 4H3, 1 year, 4 issues, USD$680, www.contratheheard.com.


The Bull & Bear Financial Report
Copyright | All Rights Reserved
Reproduction in whole or part is strictly prohibited
without prior written permission
NOTE: The Bull & Bear Financial Report does not itself endorse or guarantee
the accuracy or reliability of information, statements or opinions
expressed by any individuals or organizations posted on this site
PLEASE READ DISCLAIMER


Web Site Designed & Maintained by
Gemini Communications

This website is a publication of the
Bull & Bear Media Group, Inc.
Editor@TheBullandBear.com